There have been many attempts
in the past to make model locomotives run better. With DC Analog,
various manufacturers developed "pulse power" throttles.
Instead of providing continuous DC voltage to the motor, they would
turn power on and off with slightly higher voltage to "bump"
the loco to start. It was an improvement, but just one step in the
right direction.
Because DCC decoders control loco
speed with Pulse Width Modulation (PWM), locos
automatically get pulse power control that generally makes locos run
better than they would with normal DC Analog control. However, because
these pulses are processor controlled, they can be manipulated beyond
that - even made to be erratic, if that's what it takes to make a
loco run smooth at slow speeds.
Because of the way electric motors
work, and because of the roughness in some drive trains, it usually
takes more voltage to get a loco started than to keep it running at
a slow speed. Further, when running at low speeds, this motor/drive
train "stiction" can make a loco run erratically at slow
speeds, at best, and not slow at all at worst. While pulse power somewhat
helps with this "stiction", more can be done.
Another problem with PWM is that
it can cause a buzzing noise in some locos, especially if the frequency
matches the resonance of the loco's shell. The way to overcome this
is to increase the PWM frequency to beyond that that the human ear
can hear.
When the Pulse Width Modulation frequency
is increased to provide Quiet Drive, motor torque is lost. This is
a fact of life with electric motors. Most manufacturers don't do anything
about it. But Train Control Systems
decided to try. What they came up with is Dither. It not only returns
the torque where it's needed, but also provides a unique feature that
makes locos run smoother and better at slow speeds.
Athearn type locos benefit most from this, because they have the
most to gain.
Dither is a feature unique to Train
Control Systems decoders. It was originally developed to return lost
torque due to the increased frequency for Quiet Drive. But the side
benefit of overcoming "stiction" of lower quality locos
is just as important.
Dither adds a little extra voltage
with frequencies different than that of the normal Pulse Width Modulation.
What this does is provide some extra bumps of power at irregular times.
Because "stiction" can be immune to some frequencies, the
addition of a second variable frequency can break it.
Dither is programmed with CVs 56
and 57. Factory default for these two CVs is zero (0), which turns
Dither off.
CV56 is used to select a frequency.
The range for this CV is 0-255, with 0 (zero) being off. The highest
frequency addition of 30 extra pulses per second is obtained with
a value of 1. The higher the value, the fewer additional pulses are
added. A value of 5 is the recommended starting point, but the optimum
value is obtained through experimentation. The practical range is
1 through 10.
CV57 controls the amplitude of the
additional pulses. The range for this CV is 0-255, with 0 being off
and 255 being the highest voltage pulse. The practical range is about
5 through 50. The recommended starting value for this CV is 25 to
30. The optimum setting is again obtained through experimentation.
Dither's extra voltage bumps is provided
only in the lower 1/5 of the speed range, where it's needed. However,
it can be used in conjunction with V-Start and/or Kick
Start to provide whatever is needed to make most any loco start
and run smoothly at any speed. Yes, Train Control Systems makes Kick
Start available for use with the built-in speed table.
These three features can provide
the power manipulation needed to make almost any loco start and run
smoothly at any speed. They cannot, however, compensate for poor electrical
conductivity getting to the decoder. For more information,
refer to Athearn Improvements. |