DCC Ready usually means
the loco is ready for a DCC decoder. But DCC Ready can mean any number
of things - depending on the loco manufacturer's interpretation of
what DCC Ready really means. In this dialog, we'll start with the
"true" meaning of DCC ready, and digress to the worst interpretations
of it.
The real meaning of DCC Ready is
that the loco is pre-wired with an NMRA-recommended
socket. All you have to do to install a decoder is unplug the
dummy plug that is plugged into that socket and plug a decoder in
that has an NMRA-recommended plug that matches the socket.
Most manufacturers offer a variety
of decoders with the NMRA-recommended plug. Most use a "P"
in the part number to indicate that it has the NMRA Plug. Loy's Toys
not only offers all the plug versions offered by Digitrax and Train
Control Systems, but can install a plug on decoders that do not come
with a plug.
Further, there are many different
lengths of wire harnesses
with the plug. The standard length is about 3.5" long. Digitrax's
short harness is about 1.25" long. We make harnesses of all different
lengths, some for specific types of locos.
Even as simple as all this sounds,
some loco manufacturers fail slightly.
First, the plug is ambidextrous,
meaning it can physically be plugged in two different ways. But there's
only one correct way. It doesn't hurt anything if you plug it in backwards
- the loco will just run backwards and you won't have control of the
lights. But it would be nice if all loco manufacturers using the NMRA
socket would mark pin #1 so we'd know which way to plug the plug in.
The orange wire is supposed to be plugged into pin #1.
Second, PC boards can have shorts
that will allow the loco to run properly with the dummy plug but not
work with the decoder; or worse, fry the decoder. When you remove
the dummy plug to plug the decoder in, that is supposed to isolate
the motor and light circuits from the power pickup circuit. It's the
dummy plug that shorts these circuits together to make them work without
a decoder. But if there is a short circuit on the PC board that mirrors
the short purposely caused by the dummy plug, removing the dummy plug
does not remove that mirrored short. When a decoder is plugged in
and operated, that short circuit can fry the decoder.
While this never happens too often,
it was more prevalent in the early days of DCC, and more prevalent
with the lower-cost DCC-ready locos. Fortunately today, this is a
very rare occurrence. Never-the-less, if you want to be absolutely
sure, you can test your loco for shorts before plugging the decoder
in.
Using a multi-meter, with the dummy
plug removed, be sure that pins 4 and 8 of the loco socket do not
have continuity with pins 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, or 7. Further, be sure pins
1 and 5 do not have continuity with pins 2, 3, 6, or 7. If there is
any continuity at all, find and remove the cause of it before plugging
the decoder in.
Another type of loco that is advertised
as DCC ready are those that are designed specifically for a custom
made decoder to fit - without using the NMRA plug and socket. This
is most prevalent in N scale because there usually isn't enough room
for the NMRA socket. However, there are two drop-in decoder boards
Digitrax makes for HO scale: one for Atlas frames (DH165A0)
and one for Kato frames (DH163K0).
While this isn't exactly what was
originally meant by DCC ready, it does fit the true meaning of DCC
ready - easy installation. Typically all that's necessary to install
one of these drop-in decoders is: remove the shell, loosen the chassis,
remove the original light board, drop the decoder board in, and put
everything back together again. The HO drop-in boards Digitrax makes
require disconnection and re-connection of several wires. However,
this is easy because the replacement boards look just like the original
board and connections are in the same places. Also, connection is
with plastic caps that snap off and on. While these caps generally
work very well, some people prefer to solder the wires to the board
instead of relying on the caps.
The next level that a manufacturer
calls DCC ready is when the loco comes with a light board that has
places marked on the board to cut traces, and pads to solder the decoder
to. All of Life-Like's Proto 1000 locos have this type of board, and
at least one Proto 2000 is this way. While this is not what DCC Ready
is supposed to mean, it's really very easy.
Getting further away from what DCC
Ready really means; there are locos advertised as DCC Ready simply
because the motor is isolated from the chassis, and there is room
for the decoder. The Bachmann N scale 2-8-0 steam loco is this way.
While this makes a fairly easy hard-wired installation, it is not
really what is considered to be DCC Ready - even though it's advertised
that way. It is a hard-wired installation, not DCC ready with a socket
or set up for a drop-in decoder.
Lastly is the loco that isn't set
up for a drop-in, doesn't have an NMRA socket, and doesn't even have
a place to put the decoder, but is still advertised as DCC Ready.
While I'm sure it must be an oversight on the advertising department's
part, Atlas' new N scale GP7 loco is NOT DCC Ready. It requires frame
modification to make room for the decoder which has to be hard-wired
in. |